Blid, I would tend to agree with you solely based on aesthetic personal preferences, but I have to disagree with your umbrella statement that "anyone can objectively tell" yours is better.
I could also claim, in the same vein, that I am *obviously* a "better" W2 player than swift, not based on W2 gaming skill and experience clearly, but on friendliness, community-mindedness, newb-welcomingness, creativity, variety in map pool, speech patterns, humor, intelligence, and pretty well every category in existence other than W2 skill and monetary wealth.
But that would just be arrogant. So I won't say it.
I personally love your map. I really do. It's awesome. But the parameters for victory were set. I can also say I beat swift in every 1v1 we had because I obviously had more fun. But the amount of fun had wasn't the competition. (Though clearly, it should be.) It's just based on who can kill the opponent. The contest was based on votes. He wins.