Warcraft II Forum

Warcraft II => Server.War2.ru => Topic started by: Ishmokin on March 14, 2016, 08:29:08 AM

Title: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Ishmokin on March 14, 2016, 08:29:08 AM
Hi,

Newbie here.

Just wanted to ask what map is the most played hence I should practice more on, Classic Gow or Gow BNE?

Thanks in advance!
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: {Lance} on March 14, 2016, 09:52:59 AM
Neither.  Practice on nwtr, foc, hsc, 3v3, funfor3, pos, xmarks, friends, basically anything that is built in, thats what you should use for learning.  Learning 1 map will not help at all no matter how much it is played over others.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Yamon on March 14, 2016, 10:09:30 AM
lance sucks. It doesn't matter what maps you practice on, as long as you're not playing custom maps. However if you want to learn garden of war, you should play garden of war classic. Watching games and live streams will give you a good foundation. There are key ways to improve on war2. Playing better players consistently, remedying why you lost, and finding a mentor are all essential to learning. Keep in mind that this game is 20 years old, and if you want to compete against 20 year old veterans, you're going to need a mentor if you want to take it seriously. War2 is simply too complex to just pick up and run with at a competitive level.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: {Lance} on March 14, 2016, 10:30:40 AM
As expected,  Yamon regurgitated what I just said (play many different maps), then fucked it up by insinuating that Gow BNE and Classic Gow are similar or the same and that practicing 1 version over the other would help with the other.  That couldnt be further from the truth.  They are absolutely NOT the same and not even remotely played the same.  They are 2 DIFFERENT maps completely and played just as differently.  It seems the OP realizes this but Yamon here,  who claims to be such a great player,  failed to see this fact that even a noob could see.  That is why he asked,  he notices a difference and likely wondering which is better to learn from or played the most.  They are played about the same amount of times,  but the way in which they are played is worlds apart.  Any real player would know this.  Yamon does not qualify as a real player in any arena.  In fact,  just ignore anything he says since it originates from his Jupiter sized ego.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Certified MENSA Genius Brain (smart) on March 14, 2016, 10:54:21 AM
The fact of the matter is that non-customs players end up playing Garden of War.pud (the original) about 95% of the time.  We can talk about other classic maps all we want, but that's the truth, and if this guy wants to learn GOW, he should play and watch GOW.

Yamon recommended "Garden of war classic" and he was correct.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: {Lance} on March 14, 2016, 11:01:26 AM
Blid is right though because he does not lump Gow BNE and Gow Classic in together.  They are not the same.  When someone says "Gow",  they generally do not mean Gow BNE.  It usually references the classic Gow map.  Yamon incorrectly lumps them together :P  Gow BNE is not a classic map.  It's a battle.net edition map (get it?  B.  N.  E.  {B}attle.{Net}.{Edition}) , which in my book is not classic :)
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Certified MENSA Genius Brain (smart) on March 14, 2016, 11:02:56 AM
Lance did you misread this sentence of Yamon's? :)
 
However if you want to learn garden of war, you should play garden of war classic.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: {Lance} on March 14, 2016, 11:14:44 AM
It could be possible, but I read it that he lumped the two together and then said play Gow classic insinuating that it would help in both, which it would not.  Idk about the 95% thing though,  thats a bit extreme :)  Of course,  in my case it wouldnt be because it's actually 99.9999% hehe.  The last time I played BNE was actually on the EF speed and it was probably several months ago if not longer.  I dont really like it to be honest.  I like the non-bne gow that has 6/8/11/4 fixed, but leaves all the other spots and doesnt remove any non-buildable road paths.  I think its called Gow fixed or gow tourney, something like that, didnt you make that map? lol.  That one isnt to bad when compared to the classic gow map.  Its good for low which is really my preferred resource and probably wouldnt be a bad learning map either to learn gow as well as war2 mechanics such as being as close to the mine as possible, placing mills close to woodies, etc.  Probably not such a great map for finding a game though.  IDK how many people would join it if it were hosted :/  To bad really, its a nice map, especially on low.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Ishmokin on March 14, 2016, 01:29:11 PM
Thank you for the inputs guys.

Ok let me clarify, what would the map used in a competitive level the most? Would it be GoW classic or BNE?

I would like to learn to play the game on the map that is used in tournaments the most.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Ishmokin on March 14, 2016, 01:30:52 PM
Neither.  Practice on nwtr, foc, hsc, 3v3, funfor3, pos, xmarks, friends, basically anything that is built in, thats what you should use for learning.  Learning 1 map will not help at all no matter how much it is played over others.

Ok noted. These maps are found in the "classic" folder? or ladder folder?
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Ishmokin on March 14, 2016, 01:34:48 PM
lance sucks. It doesn't matter what maps you practice on, as long as you're not playing custom maps. However if you want to learn garden of war, you should play garden of war classic. Watching games and live streams will give you a good foundation. There are key ways to improve on war2. Playing better players consistently, remedying why you lost, and finding a mentor are all essential to learning. Keep in mind that this game is 20 years old, and if you want to compete against 20 year old veterans, you're going to need a mentor if you want to take it seriously. War2 is simply too complex to just pick up and run with at a competitive level.

I was lucky someone helped me out a few days ago and he let me observe his build by demonstrating and tutoring me on the build order, and buidling placement. Also how to wall, how to expand, and how to defend the expansion. And also, how to attack with death knights using DnD and Whirlwind. I really appreciate what he did and I guess I would like to seek more mentors like him.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Ishmokin on March 14, 2016, 01:37:34 PM
The fact of the matter is that non-customs players end up playing Garden of War.pud (the original) about 95% of the time.  We can talk about other classic maps all we want, but that's the truth, and if this guy wants to learn GOW, he should play and watch GOW.

Yamon recommended "Garden of war classic" and he was correct.

Ok noted. Will practice Garden of War Classic.  What settings should i play it at? Even Faster high res?
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: shesycompany on March 14, 2016, 02:11:59 PM
If ur human ef speed is more to your advantage ....but it basically boils down to playing with the group of people that likes what u like ...there's sea maps also gl hf!
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Certified MENSA Genius Brain (smart) on March 14, 2016, 02:17:59 PM
Even faster Garden of war is the most commonly played setting.

Also whirlwind is only a spell you lose if you're trying to rub your opponent's face in their loss.  It's just not as good as death and decay so there's no other reason to use it.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Winchester on March 14, 2016, 02:34:09 PM
lance sucks. It doesn't matter what maps you practice on, as long as you're not playing custom maps. However if you want to learn garden of war, you should play garden of war classic. Watching games and live streams will give you a good foundation. There are key ways to improve on war2. Playing better players consistently, remedying why you lost, and finding a mentor are all essential to learning. Keep in mind that this game is 20 years old, and if you want to compete against 20 year old veterans, you're going to need a mentor if you want to take it seriously. War2 is simply too complex to just pick up and run with at a competitive level.

I was lucky someone helped me out a few days ago and he let me observe his build by demonstrating and tutoring me on the build order, and buidling placement. Also how to wall, how to expand, and how to defend the expansion. And also, how to attack with death knights using DnD and Whirlwind. I really appreciate what he did and I guess I would like to seek more mentors like him.


Do you remember his name?

And before Tora came along with his tournaments, the tournaments would always be on Garden of war classic version
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: EviL~SnOoPdOgG on March 14, 2016, 02:34:36 PM
You'd better have time to play 24/7, well at least if u wanna play in the tournaments. There are players that have played this game for over 20 years or so. I've stopped trying to be the best because I don`t have the time and now I just play for fun when I can.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Yamon on March 14, 2016, 02:45:56 PM
You can ask around on war2, and everyone well tell you i am the most experienced mentor with unmatched results. My former students are:
Medivh: http://ladder.war2.ru/index.php (http://ladder.war2.ru/index.php)
Lone: http://ladder.war2.ru/player.php/php?player=lone (http://ladder.war2.ru/player.php/php?player=lone)

and this was my mentor for half a decade, swift:
http://ladder.war2.ru/player.php/php?player=swift (http://ladder.war2.ru/player.php/php?player=swift)

lone and medivh were both really new when i found them, but i could see very large potential in them. I will able to tell you if you have what it takes or not as well.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: {Lance} on March 14, 2016, 06:53:31 PM
Hmm,  I dont know about tournament play.  From what I read,  it's usually the maps that people dont play a lot of that are in those.  Maps like PoS see quite a bit of play in EF tournaments,  especially those that only have 1 round of GoW in them (if its in there at all).  I think the next EF based tourney coming up is a Loser picks type setup and you can only play a map once, whether it was a win or a loss.  So each map is only played once, regardless.  I think PoS, HSC, FoC, and Friends could see a lot of play in that.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Ishmokin on March 15, 2016, 12:52:57 AM
You'd better have time to play 24/7, well at least if u wanna play in the tournaments. There are players that have played this game for over 20 years or so. I've stopped trying to be the best because I don`t have the time and now I just play for fun when I can.

I don't plan to join the tourneys, but I plan to be a spectator and want to learn how to play in those maps. :) Or just in-house tourneys with my brother and his friends :)

I like 1v1 and was late in getting "serious" in RTS genre. I started taking it seriously when sc2 came out.  I played war 2 back in the late 90's but was ignorant of any competitive scene and strategies. When SC 1 came out my friends and i shifted to it and forgot about war 2.

  Glad to be back and my brother and I were having a blast doing 1v1 on GOW BNE. He recruiting his friends to get back playing as well :)
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Ishmokin on March 15, 2016, 12:59:13 AM
You can ask around on war2, and everyone well tell you i am the most experienced mentor with unmatched results. My former students are:
Medivh: [url]http://ladder.war2.ru/index.php[/url] ([url]http://ladder.war2.ru/index.php[/url])
Lone: [url]http://ladder.war2.ru/player.php/php?player=lone[/url] ([url]http://ladder.war2.ru/player.php/php?player=lone[/url])

and this was my mentor for half a decade, swift:
[url]http://ladder.war2.ru/player.php/php?player=swift[/url] ([url]http://ladder.war2.ru/player.php/php?player=swift[/url])

lone and medivh were both really new when i found them, but i could see very large potential in them. I will able to tell you if you have what it takes or not as well.


I would love to be mentored by you however that might be asking too much as I am just an enthusiast and not having any pro gaming ambitions.

I just need a tutor to get my skill level up to speed somewhat for serious play but not necessarily for tournament level success. 

That said I very much open to learn from you and the rest of the community. I really appreciate the help and inputs. Thank you. :)
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Yamon on March 15, 2016, 08:32:43 AM
You can ask around on war2, and everyone well tell you i am the most experienced mentor with unmatched results. My former students are:
Medivh: [url]http://ladder.war2.ru/index.php[/url] ([url]http://ladder.war2.ru/index.php[/url])
Lone: [url]http://ladder.war2.ru/player.php/php?player=lone[/url] ([url]http://ladder.war2.ru/player.php/php?player=lone[/url])

and this was my mentor for half a decade, swift:
[url]http://ladder.war2.ru/player.php/php?player=swift[/url] ([url]http://ladder.war2.ru/player.php/php?player=swift[/url])

lone and medivh were both really new when i found them, but i could see very large potential in them. I will able to tell you if you have what it takes or not as well.


I would love to be mentored by you however that might be asking too much as I am just an enthusiast and not having any pro gaming ambitions.

I just need a tutor to get my skill level up to speed somewhat for serious play but not necessarily for tournament level success. 

That said I very much open to learn from you and the rest of the community. I really appreciate the help and inputs. Thank you. :)


(http://cdn.funnyisms.com/d9378891-d46d-4767-9272-fe062fcd1d9b.gif)
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: {Lance} on March 15, 2016, 10:47:35 AM
If you can stomach Yamon's jupiter sized ego, he does have enough insight to get you pointed in the right direction.  His game is still weak but it is at least in tier 7 or 8.  Pay close attention to where he places the hall in relation to the mines around the map.  Thats about the best advice he can provide that is accurate.  Lol jk.  He should be able to give good basic starting cookbook set ups that will give you the economy you need to progress into the later stages of the game where his knowledge and experience drops off. 
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Certified MENSA Genius Brain (smart) on March 15, 2016, 10:54:15 AM
You'd better have time to play 24/7, well at least if u wanna play in the tournaments. There are players that have played this game for over 20 years or so. I've stopped trying to be the best because I don`t have the time and now I just play for fun when I can.

I don't plan to join the tourneys, but I plan to be a spectator and want to learn how to play in those maps. :) Or just in-house tourneys with my brother and his friends :)

I like 1v1 and was late in getting "serious" in RTS genre. I started taking it seriously when sc2 came out.  I played war 2 back in the late 90's but was ignorant of any competitive scene and strategies. When SC 1 came out my friends and i shifted to it and forgot about war 2.

  Glad to be back and my brother and I were having a blast doing 1v1 on GOW BNE. He recruiting his friends to get back playing as well :)
The fact is that learning rushing, walling, and res management on one map will allow you to apply them to any other map. So learning new maps, once you know the game, doesn't really involve anything more than getting a concept of what the map looks like and maybe a few minor tricks, nothing more than that.  The key is to just get that foundational knowledge of the game that you can only get from experience and watching others.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Swift on March 15, 2016, 12:51:01 PM
For learning purposes just play classic GOW, EF and nothing else. If you want to have fun play other built-in maps, but they won't really give you any insight into essential mechanics that can't already be found on classic GOW. You will still find yourself on occasion playing maps that have a certain uniqueness to them like water maps, nwtr, and ones that have more gold scarcity than you will be used to on GOW, but once you understand GOW for the most part, you will be able to pick up those maps with just a few easy adjustments.

GOW BNE is a relatively similar map to classic GOW, and the way it is played has a lot of similarities as well as long as you don't change the game speed. Hardly anyone plays it though, so you might as well be practicing on the map that people do play so you can concentrate completely on learning the tactics and maneuvers that are exclusive to classic GOW.

Yamon also gave you a great piece of advice - focus on playing people who are better than you. If you don't make this a conscious effort, you will probably find yourself unknowningly resorting to almost only playing people you can contend with and it will slow your learning process.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Yamon on March 15, 2016, 03:18:03 PM
my game is very strong, a week of unrusting and here's the results

(http://s12.postimg.org/bgjdo483h/weak.jpg)

there is also no point in the game where my knoweldge or experience fails me.
I don't even have to think. Not even lego's late game can compare to mine.

Here's an ss of a 45 minute game vs lego with the watchers accusing me of hacking.

It's easy because swift taught me everything i'll ever need to know about early,mid, and late game.

(http://s16.postimg.org/eixo1bq5x/image.jpg)
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Certified MENSA Genius Brain (smart) on March 15, 2016, 03:21:30 PM
Didn't you say Medivh is your student?  How come you haven't taught him to beat you yet?
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Swift on March 15, 2016, 03:27:09 PM
More importantly, why do you have two losses to Medivh? And, why is Medivh losing to you?

Seems pretty embarrassing for both sides.  :-[
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Yamon on March 15, 2016, 03:31:05 PM
More importantly, why do you have two losses to Medivh? And, why is Medivh losing to you?

Seems pretty embarrassing for both sides.  :-[

2nd week back on war2.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Yamon on March 15, 2016, 03:31:41 PM
Didn't you say Medivh is your student?  How come you haven't taught him to beat you yet?
i have. he's beaten me countless times, but the student never surpasses the master.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: {Lance} on March 15, 2016, 03:53:59 PM
Didn't you say Medivh is your student?  How come you haven't taught him to beat you yet?

^-- Ya what he said.

And table the ego Yamon,  it's disgusting,  always has been, always will be.  Why dont you post the warvid of the 12/2 beatdown that I handed you while you cried that your partners didnt help?  I didnt receive help, so the crying was unwarranted.  Then you proceeded to stomp off in a hissy fit leaving the game 20 minutes early instead of stick around to play again once the game finished.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Yamon on March 15, 2016, 05:02:57 PM
Didn't you say Medivh is your student?  How come you haven't taught him to beat you yet?


^-- Ya what he said.



And table the ego Yamon,  it's disgusting,  always has been, always will be.  Why dont you post the warvid of the 12/2 beatdown that I handed you while you cried that your partners didnt help?  I didnt receive help, so the crying was unwarranted.  Then you proceeded to stomp off in a hissy fit leaving the game 20 minutes early instead of stick around to play again once the game finished.



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2k0SmqbBIpQ (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2k0SmqbBIpQ)
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Ishmokin on March 16, 2016, 01:36:33 AM
For learning purposes just play classic GOW, EF and nothing else. If you want to have fun play other built-in maps, but they won't really give you any insight into essential mechanics that can't already be found on classic GOW. You will still find yourself on occasion playing maps that have a certain uniqueness to them like water maps, nwtr, and ones that have more gold scarcity than you will be used to on GOW, but once you understand GOW for the most part, you will be able to pick up those maps with just a few easy adjustments.

GOW BNE is a relatively similar map to classic GOW, and the way it is played has a lot of similarities as well as long as you don't change the game speed. Hardly anyone plays it though, so you might as well be practicing on the map that people do play so you can concentrate completely on learning the tactics and maneuvers that are exclusive to classic GOW.

Yamon also gave you a great piece of advice - focus on playing people who are better than you. If you don't make this a conscious effort, you will probably find yourself unknowningly resorting to almost only playing people you can contend with and it will slow your learning process.


Sure will do. Will practice on classic GOW and will be actively seeking out better players (in this case anyone in War2 server haha). Yup losing doesn't bother me, i see it as learning opportunities.  It's very similar to Fighting games, Dont be afraid of losing to better players. In the process I get better.

I got my ass handed to me constantly the other day, took a beating, but in the process I experience for the first time someone building a Rax in front of my gold mine and me didnt know who to handle it. I guess the key is to not let that Peon inside the base.

Looking forward to playing in the war2 server alot. Many thanks to you all for the advice!
 Cheers!:)
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: {Lance} on March 16, 2016, 02:16:44 AM
the easiest way to deal with a rax is to build 2 or more guard towers in your own base that are in target range of the rax (but that dont impead your own gold flow once its down) so that it dies faster and kills any grunts that pop out of it.  But you'll also need to make sure they are not towering you as well.  If they are,  always stay 1 tower ahead and you will always win because they wasted res on a rax and you didnt.

Once you get better,  you'll also be able to kill the rax AND do the same thing to them and pressure them at their base and then you'll find that killing the rax at your base becomes MUCH easier since they are busy looking at their base while you are kicking their ass ;)  In a neighbor war vs 2 good players,  you'll see that both players pressure the other and at the same time are still able to fend off the other's attack.  The result is usually that no one dies right away but both players are significantly slowed.  The player slowed the most,  usually ends up losing later in the game.

The idea behind the whole pscout neighbor thing is to kill your neighbor if you can, but if not,  then the goal is to slow them more than they can slow you.  You'll be able to tell what their intentions are by what they build in your town.  If they build a rax,  then they have no intentions of killing you quickly.  Their intentions are to slow your gold flow as soon as possible and slow you as much as they can.  Doing this is MUCH easier than trying to kill them quickly with guard towers so many many players will opt to rax you rather than kill you with GT's.  Better players will actually do BOTH rax and kill you with GT's,  but that requires excellent resource management and is usually only effective if its done by a seasoned player who can assess the situation instantly and know exactly what to do and not do,  determine if something has a high probability of success based on the layout of the board,  etc.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: mousEtopher on March 16, 2016, 09:42:16 AM
Sure will do. Will practice on classic GOW and will be actively seeking out better players (in this case anyone in War2 server haha). Yup losing doesn't bother me, i see it as learning opportunities.  It's very similar to Fighting games, Dont be afraid of losing to better players. In the process I get better. I got my ass handed to me constantly the other day, took a beating, but in the process I experience for the first time someone building a Rax in front of my gold mine and me didnt know who to handle it. I guess the key is to not let that Peon inside the base. Looking forward to playing in the war2 server alot. Many thanks to you all for the advice!  Cheers!:)

I'm garbage at gow so probably at or close to your level (if you aren't already better than me :D), let's 1v1 sometime

Yamon, I've forgotten 99% of our gow lessons, can I get a refresher? c:
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Ishmokin on March 16, 2016, 11:04:17 AM
@Mousetopher

Sure! I'm always game for a 1v1  :D
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: LuX on March 18, 2016, 03:02:06 PM
The real question is can Yamon beat me once out of 10 games.
Title: Re: Which version of GOW should I practice more on?
Post by: Yamon on March 19, 2016, 03:07:02 PM
Sure will do. Will practice on classic GOW and will be actively seeking out better players (in this case anyone in War2 server haha). Yup losing doesn't bother me, i see it as learning opportunities.  It's very similar to Fighting games, Dont be afraid of losing to better players. In the process I get better. I got my ass handed to me constantly the other day, took a beating, but in the process I experience for the first time someone building a Rax in front of my gold mine and me didnt know who to handle it. I guess the key is to not let that Peon inside the base. Looking forward to playing in the war2 server alot. Many thanks to you all for the advice!  Cheers!:)

I'm garbage at gow so probably at or close to your level (if you aren't already better than me :D), let's 1v1 sometime

Yamon, I've forgotten 99% of our gow lessons, can I get a refresher? c:


hit me up when you're on war2